Schmidlap wrote:
novaderrik wrote:
...now it just looks like a bloated monstrosity, and it's not even based on a truck chassis any more?
The Grand Cherokee has been a unibody frame since it was introduced almost 20 years ago and I've never heard anybody complain about its capabilities, so why should the Explorer stick to a body on frame design when 99.999999% of users will never even notice the difference? It can still tow 5000lbs, which is only 375lb less than the last generation V6 Explorer, but 2000lb less than the old V8 Explorer. An F150 with the non-turbo V6 can only tow 5500-6100lb depending on the final drive ratio, so the BOF design didn't help much there. Should Ford go with a BOF simply to improve towing 10-20%? Should they have developed a whole new platform, or heavily revised the Ranger platform just for this vehicle? That would have dramatically raised the price, and cut the profitability of the Explorer, not to mention that the maximum a Ranger can only tow is 6000lbs. Sure, you could argue that they could go with a BOF design and put a 5L V8 in it and suddenly the Explorer could tow 9000lb, but then you've just got a slightly smaller Expedition.
The new Explorer was the #6 best selling SUV in the US in September, so Ford must have done something right. The only vehicle in the top 10 that had a BOF was the Wrangler, and it only beat the Explorer by 50 sales. The number 1 selling was the Escape, the CRV was #2, Equinox #3, the Edge was #4. People don't want SUVs that are based on a truck frame. Source
Bob
actually, Jeeps have been unibodies for closer to 30 years than 20 years.. but this isn't about having frames or not- it's about calling something a truck that isn't a truck any more.. it's a tall station wagon that they hit really, really hard with the fugly stick. the car makers love these kinds of vehicles because they can sell them at an insane profit margin and they don't take a CAFE hit on their car lines because they are somehow considered to be "trucks" instead of the full size station wagons that they really are. this is also why they've pushed things like the HHR and PT Cruiser- which are just small station wagons built on passenger car chassis that are somehow classified as light trucks for emissions, crash worthiness, and fuel economy rating reasons.
hey, people can buy what they want and the makers can make what they think the people will buy.. my opinion doesn't really matter much- i wouldn't buy anything new even if i could actually afford it. everything- yes, everything- except for the new Corvette and the base V6 Camaro is just flat out fugly and has too many nanny state gizmos on them.. even my relatively simple '04 Cavalier is right on the borderline of being too complicated for my tastes.